Martha Stewart Ditched White Sneakers for These Comfy, Unexpectedly Stylish Crocs (Again)

When Martha Stewart wears a pair of shoes once, we take notes. But when she wears the same option nonstop all summer? We add it to our carts immediately — which is the case with these comfy Crocs sandals. Lucky for Us, Stewart’s exact pair is marked down right now!

Stewart reached for the Crocs Y-Strap Sandals while attending the 2026 Masters Tournament, celebrating the Knicks’ championship win, strolling around New York City and more. It’s no surprise she owns the style in multiple colors, and with a price tag of just $45, we’re tempted to follow her lead!

Get the Crocs Soho Y-Strap Sandals for $45 (was $60) at Amazon! Please note, prices are accurate at the date of publication but are subject to change.

These Stewart-approved Soho Y-Strap Sandals land somewhere between practical walking shoes and ones you’d wear to a Hamptons lunch. The silhouette is sleeker than a clog, featuring a stylish double-strap design and a height-boosting platform.

However, it’s the feel that makes these chic sandals a no-brainer. The classic Crocs footbed ensures your feet aren’t screaming after farmers’ market runs and afternoon errands, offering support, stability and cloud-like comfort.

One happy reviewer called them “great for all-day walking” and wrote, “I was always battling blisters on my feet and toes in different tennis shoes, and I feel like my feet suffocate in closed-toed shoes all day. I walked five miles at Magic Kingdom today, and my feet did not ache, blister or swell! They are so bouncy and supportive.”

“These Crocs are so comfortable,” said another happy fan. “You feel like walking in a cloud, and it gives you a little height! The color is fabulous, plus I got a lot of looks and compliments!”

Whether you wear the sandals with dresses, matching sets or tailored white pants like Stewart, you’re bound to appear effortlessly stylish.

Stewart’s endorsement is unspoken but loud. If she’s wearing these rubber shoes on repeat, that’s all we need to know. Snag her pair before it sells out, and hurry!

Get the Crocs Soho Y-Strap Sandals for $45 (was $60) at Amazon! Please note, prices are accurate at the date of publication but are subject to change.

Looking for something else? Explore more chic sandals, and don’t forget to check out all of Amazon’s Daily Deals for more great finds!

UsNow Summer Sale Alert: These Chic Fashion Finds are over 30% off – Plus Free Shipping
Welcome to summer with our biggest sale of the year. This summer’s chicest dresses, tops and swimsuits are all over 30% + free shipping. Inventory is limited so hurry before they’re gone.
Shop the UsNow Summer Sale –>