Robyn Lively Reunites with Teen Witch Cast 35 Years Later: ‘Unsuspecting Treasure’

There are plenty of pop culture witches who have made their mark, though one that holds a special place in ’80s kids’ hearts is Louise Miller from Teen Witch.

Despite not being a huge box office success at the time of its 1989 release, it’s lived on as one of the more memorable depictions of teenage witches – and to celebrate the film’s anniversary, the cast reunited.

On Oct. 24, Robyn Lively posted photos of herself with her former costars, adding side-by-side shots of the cast in the late ’80s and now.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“I can hardly believe it’s been that many years that we made this unsuspecting treasure,” Lively captioned the post, which started with a side-by-side of her and onscreen love interest Dan Gauthier. 

“Having the opportunity to meet so many of you that love this film, to read your delightful and sometimes heart wrenching comments here… you guys will never know how much it means to me,” Lively continued. “So thank you, for sharing a piece of your heart and experiences with me! Teen Witch fans are the absolute BEST! You have my heart!”

Teen Witch followed 15-year-old Louise Miller (played by Lively) who discovered she was the reincarnation of a 17th-century witch after developing powers on her 16th birthday. She used these newfound powers to bring herself the popularity and love she’d desired from her peers, thanks to a little help from seer Madame Serena.

With these powers, she cast a love spell on her high-school crush, quarterback Brad Powell (Gauthier). In between musical numbers and moments of onscreen magic, Louise eventually tries to reverse the teenage dreams she’s manifested into reality with her magic.

Lively has previously admitted that despite not gaining notoriety at the time of its release, it continues to be one of her most recognized roles.

“Teen Witch holds the number one spot for decades now,” she shared with PEOPLE. “Nothing compares. People absolutely love that film, and it’s resonated with so many generations. I had no idea when we were filming it that it would end up being … I just had no clue. It’s so dear and beloved to me because of that.”