Married at First Sight: David Is Confronted About Affair as Madison Insists Michelle ‘Didn’t Give a S—‘ About Him (Exclusive)

David is showing no regrets about his affair with Madison.

In PEOPLE’s exclusive sneak peek of the Feb. 25 “Decision Day” episode of Married at First Sight, David is confronted by Thomas about the cheating scandal.

“For me, it’s important as a friend — if I call myself a friend to you — to hold you accountable, because that’s what friends do,” Thomas says, to which David replies, “100%.” 

“You know, you stand up with your friends, and even when they do wrong, you stand up with them, but later you’re like, ‘Okay, what the f—?’” Thomas says before questioning when the affair began.

He continues to press David for his own “peace of mind,” asking, “Is this something like, did it start a long time ago? Or is this something where you guys [were] just friends, and then, you know?”

David admits the affair “started off at the gym… as a complete friendship.” He explains, “I was getting the communication, I was getting the attention, and just asking questions of who I was.” 

“So that, right there, meant a s— ton to me, to where, and probably started growing, after that,” he adds before Madison chimes in, “I think mine and Allen’s situation was 100% different than David and Michelle’s.” 

She claims that the cast was aware that David’s relationship was on the rocks, saying, “I think all of us knew that Michelle and David were not going to be together at the end of this. She didn’t give a s— about David.” 

Her allegation causes Michelle to turn her head as she pours a drink at the bar. She then asks Madison, “You want to wait ‘til I get over there?”

“Sure, come sit down, I’ll gladly say it,” Madison replies.

On an episode of Married at First Sight earlier this month, Madison admitted she was no longer interested in pursuing a relationship with Allen and instead, had feelings for David.

“I do like you, probably more than I should. I just wanted to be honest with you, and I don’t think that I can probably continue in my marriage personally,” she confessed.

“I don’t think it’s fair to Allen and I know that it’s messy and I think that this could be something,” Madison added.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Married at First Sight (produced by Kinetic Content) airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET on Lifetime.