Bachelorette Star Gabby Windey Got Married in a $1,490 Wedding Dress That She Joked Made Her Butt Look ‘Huge’

Gabby Windey and her wedding dress were a match made in heaven! 

The Traitors star, 34, opened up about her recent nuptials to her writer and comedian girlfriend, Robby Hoffman, 35, in an interview with Cosmopolitan, published March 5. She revealed that her dress for her big day was the first one she saw when she entered the store. 

“At first I wanted to go full Kourtney Kardashian, where she went in casual leather and Prada sunglasses, but we wanted to do our own thing,” Windey told the outlet of her wedding. “I went into department stores and the first dress I saw on the mannequin was off-white lace, and I was like, ‘This is gonna be it.’ ”

And she was right. As soon as the reality TV star tried on the dress, she knew it was the one. “It was the only one they had in stock,” she said. “It was a little tight and made my butt look huge, but it was perfect.”

Her dress, as seen in a March 5 Instagram post, was an ivory lace Rabanne gown with a high neckline that retails for $1,490 on FWRD. The dress featured other lace details on the bodice and below the hips. For her wedding day, Windey paired the off-the-rack dress with simple, white stilettos with a pointed toe. 

As for the overall wedding, the Bachelorette alum told the outlet, “Everything just fell into place so naturally. It felt so serendipitous and so precious and so meant to be.” Hoffman agreed, adding, “I actually can’t believe how perfect it was. It was the best wedding I’ve ever been to.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Windey revealed in the aforementioned Instagram post that she and Hoffman were married in a secret ceremony on Jan. 11, 2025, in a Las Vegas chapel. She told Cosmopolitan that their wedding day totaled just $799, including a limousine and minister. 

The former Dancing With the Stars competitor also shared that she and Hoffman — who began dating in August 2023 — chose to tie the knot after fleeing to Las Vegas following the Los Angeles fires.

“We had just evacuated from the fires. Literally cue Rihanna, ‘We found love in a hopeless place,’ ” Windey said. “What better time to get married than right now? Because if the world is ending, we want to be with each other.”